Follow sprtopinionated on Twitter

Popular Posts

  • Speculating on Whether Regehr Should be Traded by the Flames reggie

    Based on a few comments on the Illegal Curve radio show, I put up a post on Matchsticks & Gasoline yesterday about the Flames potential to trade Regehr and why it’s time to do so.

    The article is posted here.

    Below is an excerpt from the article.

    “Now before everyone gets their guard up and says Regehr is [...]

    • Share/Bookmark
  • Posted on HP: NHL Team Architecture nashville draft

    Here is a study that I did for Hockey Prospectus on NHL Team Architecture.  Obviously since I posted it on HP, I believe they have a great site, so definitely take a look at some of the material from their other great writers too.

    Front Office Focus – NHL Team Architecture 

    What is the best way to [...]

    • Share/Bookmark
  • Jay Bouwmeester: Disappointment or Not Used Properly? J-Bo

    This is a story I posted on Matchsticks & Gasoline as part of our player preview series.  Come take a look at some of the other articles if you’re interested.

    Sometimes things just don’t work out like we thought.  Items bought on eBay looked better in the picture than when they arrive in the mail, your [...]

    • Share/Bookmark
  • Fireman Ed Should Pour a Stiff Drink fireman ed

    Rex Ryan may be the king of the F-bombs, but he better use as many as he can during the regular season.  The Jets won’t be making the playoffs.

    The Jets used up all their luck last year.  There are no playoff-bound cakewalk games at the end of this season’s schedule.  Opposing kickers are all out [...]

    • Share/Bookmark
  • What is Darrelle Revis Worth to the Jets? revis

    Revis Island can be a lonely place for receivers.  At the moment it’s also a lonely place for a Darrelle Revis.  The man who was hands-down the best defensive player in the league last year is not practicing or spending time with his teammates, and it HAS to be a frustrating way to follow up [...]

    • Share/Bookmark

Archives

Featured On

S-O on Twitter

Sports Sharing

What's worse, Fan-beaters or Cheerleaders?

I had to give myself some time before I commented on the big fan interaction problem infecting the NHL right now.  I’m not talking about the whole “Rick Rypien fan-grab” controversy, mainly because it’s not a controversy.  Let me break it down for you:

Dude is fired up from a hockey fight.  Fan says something to dude, even if it’s not THAT offensive.  Dude gets mad at fan and makes a move towards him. 

Basically, we just described a similar situation to what happens at the bar between men in their 20’s every night of the week.  The only difference here is that one guy is a pro athlete who is paid to be aggressive towards other men.  Yes, he’s paid to be aggressive. 

I’m not saying it’s right, I’m just saying it’s not that shocking.  I don’t condone what Rypien did, but I’m not sure I would have done better.  Without knowing for sure what the fan said, we can judge Rypien only with half the information.  He was clearly provoked to some degree, but he’s responsible for his own actions.

Hell, I cheered for Tie Domi during this fan altercation, and I was never really a fan of Domi in the first place.  In this case, the fan deserved it.  Don’t pick a fight you can’t actually win.

The issue that actually has me fired up, though, is one that hasn’t got the same headlines.  The Edmonton Oilers have become the first Canadian NHL team to add a cheerleading squad.  Apparently the “City of Champions” has given up on not only this year’s team, but their franchise’s relevance as well.

Canadian hockey teams don’t need cheerleaders. 

Cheerleaders are a gimmick to entertain people who can’t pay attention to the game.  If a Canadian city can’t fill a hockey rink with fans who actually want to see the game, then they’ve lost touch in the form of pricing, marketing or the team is just terrible.  Edmonton should need this less than most cities.

Edmonton is probably in a dead heat with Montreal and Toronto for the most fanatical, loyal hockey fan base in the world.  And they are much more rational and supportive fans than those from the East.  The Oilogosphere contains some of the most influential and insightful fan-generated content on the sport.  This is hardly a city who breeds fans that need eye-candy just to attend.

Remember, this praise is coming from a guy who has supported the Flames since I could hold a hockey stick.

The Edmonton Oilers need cheerleaders like XM needs another channel dedicated to a single band.

Cheerleaders mean the game needs sex and glitter to be entertaining and the product clearly isn’t good enough.

If the Oilers are trying to spice up the game-time atmosphere with a team that is clearly a few years away, I’ve got a better option.  Turn off the scoreboard-induced fake cheers and hire some super-fans.  Have them go to Europe and attend a soccer match.  Learn about team songs and chants.  Start selling Oilers scarves and banners.  Work up an add campaign that challenges the fans to provide the best home atmosphere in the league.

Take a look at this video and tell me the average sports fan wouldn’t prefer this over watching a few cheerleaders dance at the game. 

I like beautiful girls as much as the next guy.  I’m married man in his mid-thirties, so I’m probably in the demographic the cheerleaders are supposed to be targeting.  But I’d rather we left the flesh-marketing to Victoria’s Secret and focused hockey fan’s attention on the ice and creating a great atmosphere to watch a game.

Buzz it!

No related posts.

1 comment to What’s worse, Fan-beaters or Cheerleaders?

  • I hate hate hate the idea that cheerleaders are there to distract from what’s on the ice. I’m sorry, that’s bull. Cheerleaders entertain during intermissions, stoppages in play, etc. I guarantee you, having watched cheerleaders my whole life, that they will not be bouncing around or something during play.

    Cheerleaders have nothing to do with the game not being entertaining. It’s just a cultural product seeping from our side of the border. If someone is attending a game because of cheerleaders- then they clearly don’t have the internet at home. Fact is, 90% of things at hockey games that aren’t the game itself are no different than cheerleaders. Mascot races, little kids playing a game, t-shirt tosses, fancy videos, laser shows, having a giant shark’s mouth to race out of. If anything, those are all worse than cheerleaders. At least the cheerleaders, you know, cheer.

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>